Anachronistic Morality

When I was growing up we attended church regularly. And as we listened to sermons and/or attended “Sunday school” one thing became clear: the Israelites (ancient Jews) “just didn’t get it!”

I mean, they might cross the Red Sea, miraculously rescued from the Egyptians by the hand of God, then turn around and grumble and complain about the manna they were given to help them survive in the desert.

Or Moses would go up Mt. Sinai to receive the Ten Commandments, and by the time he came back down (40 days) they would be worshiping a golden calf in the valley below.

As Christians we would read these stories, always perplexed at how clueless the Jewish people were; they would be delivered from harm by their Deity, and then (in the words of Isaiah 57:5) they would turn and “burn with lust among the oaks and under every spreading tree.”

They were recalcitrant, rebellious, incorrigible and ungrateful (see Psalm 106 for a more comprehensive indictment)!

Sometimes we would look at how they treated Jesus, and how their leaders were able to turn them into an unruly and riotous crowd shouting “Crucify him.” And we would be aghast at their callous, uninformed, peer-pressured actions. We felt we were so much wiser, had so much more character and loyalty about us.

Then . . . on occasion . . . someone might refer to the phrase, “So, if you think you are standing firm, be careful that you don’t fall!” (1 Corinthians 10:12)

But falling is what we had done. We had fallen victim to (among other things) what I would coin “anachronistic morality,”  i.e. imposing our modern morality (which we had assumed was on a higher plain) upon people of the past. In other words:

we thought they knew better, but wouldn’t do better.

And in a similar pattern we are now living in a time when the heroes of past generations are being judged by current moral ideals. We must avoid promoting illegitimate historical revisionism.

It is nearly impossible to put oneself accurately in the place of someone living in another time period, and fairly judge his/her point of view, mindset, prejudices, motives and contradictions. And obviously, the further away that person is from our own time period and culture, the difficulty increases.

Honor is awarded at specific moments in time; the specific moments may not be celebrated for all time. Monuments are created to commemorate the work or sacrifice of persons engaged in what is deemed valiant, worthy, and courageous in a given time.

Clearly, there are always parameters kept in mind. But those parameters are determined by the collective moral compass of the individuals giving the honor. Around the world there are commemorative monuments and plaques, and you would be hard-pressed to find one that either honors someone/something never embroiled in controversy, or was created by someone whose personal moral compass does not match your own.

We seem not to be disturbed by this when we honor celebrities: entertainers, scientists, writers, etc. But outside that realm our tone and tolerance changes.

Over fifteen years ago I visited Mauthausen with a group of home school teenagers. It was an unforgettable reminder of the horrors of the holocaust. I am not glad so many died there (their pictures covering the wall where the ovens were). But I am glad that it still stands, today, and that it can be visited by tourists. Because it makes the fact of the atrocities more of a reality to people in current generations.

I do not know the answers to all the social questions that are inundating us in America, today. We seem to be floating in turmoil right now, our heads barely above the surface. But I don’t think our current struggles are helped much by reaching into the past and trying to find new ways to denigrate the heroes of our past. We need them now more than ever. They are our life preservers.

And so, ancient Israelites . . . I will let up on you a bit. I may be as unpliable as you were. Maybe more so.

About ivanbenson

I am a former singer, guitar player, writer, story teller, voice over talent, and a current heart attack survivor in the Atlanta, Georgia area.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Anachronistic Morality

  1. ivanbenson says:

    Excellent points. Thanks for taking the time to read, discuss, and comment on the article.

  2. Jonathan Sartain says:

    Me and my dad were actually just discussing this issue. Well said. In addition to what you mentioned in the article, I believe a large part of the problem is that everyone in history must either be an archetypal hero or a malicious villain. We leave no room for sinners who have done great things. I see no good reason not to recognize the great things these men and women did, while also recognizing their faults for what they are. This all being viewed through the lens of the grace and forgiveness we’ve received from our own evil actions. It’s easy to make someone the villain because they sin differently than us. It keeps us from having to acknowledge how terrible our own sin is. Especially if that person is far displaced from our culture and time. I wonder how many of them would see us if they used the same filter we’ve set up in reverse. Not to kindly, I would imagine. There are probably a host of issues I have that would appall the giants whose shoulders I stand on, if those giants viewed them through the lens of their time. Thank you for your time on this well thought out post Ivan.

  3. ivanbenson says:

    Thank you for reading and commenting, Paula. I appreciate your insights and honesty.

  4. Paula Gilman says:

    Ivan, I think you hit the nail on the head. I know that as I study the Old Testament history of Israel, I continually have two responses: how thick-headed Israel was and how incredibly patient God was with them!
    We are like Israel in that we continue to miss the mark, taking the same tests over and over and once in a while passing, only to go on to flunk the next. Yet all the while, the Test-Giver, allows us to re-take until we pass, helping us along lovingly, patiently, but then upping the challenge a little more…. Sanctification. How patient He has been with me!
    I agree that the current tide seems to not ride on current behaviors, but past ones, to find fault and issue judgements. God calls us to compare ourselves only to Christ, nothing or no one else to judge our own fairness, integrity, and character. He is the only One who does NOT change over time, Who is the same yesterday, today, and forever!
    Thanks, Ivan .

  5. ivanbenson says:

    Thank you, my dear.

  6. Suzanne says:

    Very interesting perspective!

  7. ivanbenson says:

    We are fine, Bob. Thanks. Crazy times we are living in, huh? As to who I had in mind re: heroes, the list is endless. But for starters . . . how about Abraham Lincoln, John F. Kennedy, Moses, and a host of others. The prompt was renewed criticism of famous figures that we once venerated.

  8. Bob Russell says:

    Hi Ivan. How are you and Monica doing? Hope both of you and all of your family are staying healthy.

    I’m curious. What prompted this post and to whom are you referring that were “heroes of past generations”?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.